DT better with Edward Payne?
 

I really think that DinoThunder would have been better with Edward as the mentor instead of Tommy. You wouldn't have had to shoehlrn Tommy into an unrelated storylines. Nor would Tommy hog the spotlight. Also you wouldn't have that stupid stuck morphed storyline.

Re: DT better with Edward Payne?
 

It would have still been good. But you would have lost some lf the specialness the real DT had without Tommy's big return.

Re: DT better with Edward Payne?
 

I disagree and I don't know what planet you're on but he wasn't hogging the spotlight in Dino Thunder

Re: DT better with Edward Payne?
 

They did a great job not overexposing him. A lot of DT was carried by the three core Rangers.

Re: DT better with Edward Payne?
 

I don't see how it would have been better without the Tommy return? Would it still have bden good? Probably...But why get rid of something that was good for the season?

Re: DT better with Edward Payne?
 

Because some of us are sick of Tommy and sse through what a terrible and damaging character he was to the brand.

Re: DT better with Edward Payne?
 

I think it would have been about the same. I don't think Doctor Oliver hogged the zpotlight like he did in the past. The say they presented the characters was balanced.

Re: DT better with Edward Payne?
 

some of you maybe but to say he was a damaging character to the brand is an insult and offensive if anything is damaging to the brand it's you Hater Dudes who go out of their way to bash a fictional character which just makes you look completely foolish, dumb, idiotic and moronic.

Re: DT better with Edward Payne?
 

I think Tommy Oliver returning as a mentor was a much more interesting hook than some guynname Edward Payne.

Re: DT better with Edward Payne?
 

Tommy was the only thing that made DinoThunder watchable. He was great in it. I don't care about Edward Payne. I am just glad they weren't dumb enough to bring Kat back as his wife. If only they brought Kim back

Re: DT better with Edward Payne?
 

Only if Edward Payne was modeled off of AbaBlack. If he wasn't from the Dino Demension ir would have been a waste anyway. I wasn't a fan of American Burai coming back. Since he is such a symbol of when American Sentai was at its worst.

Re: DT better with Edward Payne?
 

Eh I am glad they didn 't include dino earth or not the Evorian. It all looked so goofy.

Re: DT better with Edward Payne?
 

I agree, DT was much more interesting with Tommy instead of Payne.

Re: DT better with Edward Payne?
 

definitely not in fact the only thing that is at its worst is you and your other Sentai Snobs.

I would have to agree on that.

Re: DT better with Edward Payne?
 

Who is Edward Payne?

Re: DT better with Edward Payne?
 

He was the back up for Doctor Oliver in case they failed to get JDF to sign the dotted line. Word leaked out about Tommy's return before the deal was done. So they had to deny it and put out the Payne bios until JDF was officially signed.

Re: DT better with Edward Payne?
 

I think Jason should have been the mentor. Since he was one of the originals. But Tommy was a lot better than a newbie mentor.

Re: DT better with Edward Payne?
 

I think they just should have continued NS with Abaranger Footage

Re: DT better with Edward Payne?
 

PR already got rid of the albatross and learned to live withlut him. There was no need to bring him back. I can almost understand FR but DT and LB? And now SNS?. I will not count the movie cameo. Since it was just JDF playing a cilvlian fpr 10 seconds.

Re: DT better with Edward Payne?
 

Yes, it waa dumb how American Sentai has always tried to bring back American Burai.

Re: DT better with Edward Payne?
 

And they didn't even adapt him right in the first place. Toei must have been pissed! I don't get why they didn't step in back then. It would have been grounds to cancel PR and take back their rights in the west. They could have given us dubbed Sentai or at least an exact translation.

Re: DT better with Edward Payne?
 

No way! Why would you not use the chance to bring back an old favorite? Especially when you could have Jason David Frank?

Re: DT better with Edward Payne?
 

I could live with JDF coming back if he was playing Edward Payne. Or another senario where a new actor was playing a different Tommy Oliver.

Re: DT better with Edward Payne?
 

Disney wisely decided to bring Frank back. Since they knew the fans would love it!

Re: DT better with Edward Payne?
 

Keep telling yourself that.

Re: DT better with Edward Payne?
 

I don't see how anyone can seriously argue brining back Tommy was better then using Edward Payne?

Re: DT better with Edward Payne?
 

That is the only thing that would have made it better

Re: DT better with Edward Payne?
 

I would much rather have an older Tommy then a new character as mentor.Its not like Tommy was the exact same character we last saw in Turbo. He matured and changed.

Re: DT better with Edward Payne?
 

My only complaint is that they seemed to forget the way Tommy was presented in FR. I thibk Mercer should have been the antagonistic teacher all year. Tommy could have been an older businessman that the Rangers become mixed up with by chance. Tommy also should have been Zeo Red until he becomes Black Ranger.

Re: DT better with Edward Payne?
 

If your gonna do that why not have Black Ranger be a new character. To my could then fight sporadically as Zeo Red. And perhaps be the one who becomes Trassic Ranger?

Re: DT better with Edward Payne?
 

Call me crazy but I would have been fine with Edward Payne. He could have been an interesting new character. Tommye already had a great swan song in Forever Red.

Re: DT better with Edward Payne?
 

The Tommy we got in DT wasn't the true Tommy. It was very disappointing that they messed this up , as well as the whole season. I wouldn't have cwred about Payne either.

Re: DT better with Edward Payne?
 

You know I never really watched MMPR when it was originaly on or many of the Tommy episiodes during his first run. But I really liked Tommy based on DinoThunder and the old episodes of him that I have seen! He was awesome in FR.

Re: DT better with Edward Payne?
 

don't be ridiculous the one we saw in Dino Thunder is as true to the character that we saw in MMPR-Turbo and Wild Force

Re: DT better with Edward Payne?
 

I agree. It's just Disney didn't want Tommy cursing, i.e. insulting villains in a humorous way like with Goldar (like "Overgrown flying monkey") and karate-yelling during butt-kicking all of the time. So JDF had to minimize that part. Well, the "Fighting Spirit" scene when he throws the monster right into that wall is an exception. That scene is 110 % Tommy, along with Tommy's coma dream when he fights against his Ranger forms (MM Green, MM White and Zeo V).

Re: DT better with Edward Payne?
 

Tommy would have to be a different since he was several years older. It would be silly if he acted exactly the same. Plus he was the Rangers mentor instead of a peer. Thats a much different dynamic.

Re: DT better with Edward Payne?
 

He even acted more mature in Forever Red. Plus it appeared like Bulk and Skull were calling him "Sir". This clearly tells us that:
1. Tommy went trough a lot since the end of his time as a Turbo Ranger and Forever Red.
2. Something clearly happened between him, Bulk and Skull since they referred to him as they did in the episode. The two former bullies, cops and detectives clearly did something wrong and went over the line and Tommy happened to be there so he must have done something about it. It's either that or he helped Bulk and Skull get their jobs.

Re: DT better with Edward Payne?
 

There is no doubt a lot happened. It was funny seeing Bulk and Skull kiss up to Tommy. FR seemed to imply he was rich. That part was left out of DT. But then again how did Doctor O pay for his lab?

Re: DT better with Edward Payne?
 

That's right. If Tommy's rich, it means he has people working for him. Which means he can afford a lab. Plus there was someone in DT who had a de-morph issue.

Re: DT better with Edward Payne?
 

It actually makes sense that Tommy would be rich. And when ypunthink about it, nothing DinoThunder does contradicts that idea. As mentioned, the lab wasn't cheap. And being rich doesn't prevent you from being a teacher. Anton did it too.