PR News 05/19/08 - PR 2009 Title Revealed! - Page 4

Harlan Phoenix · 04/21/08, 05:34 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by PrimoPiccolo

But those seasons also had producers who really tried to fight the status quo. If Kalish is still under contract for next year, we'll see a 96% Go-onger translation, because all the stuff that made S.P.D. independent of Dekaranger was thanks to Greg Aronowitz.

Isn't Kalish working on something new after Jungle Fury?

PrimoPiccolo · 04/21/08, 06:56 PM

Not that I know of. But I'm far from well-informed on the inner workings of PR.

Personally, I think Kalish has had enough time at the reigns. Sloan did the first four and a half seasons, Tzachor the next five and a half, so a PR ingenue like Kalish getting four is plenty.

And while it's been said thousands of times on thousands of boards before, once more won't hurt: Jackie needs to be in charge.

red timeforce ranger · 04/21/08, 08:21 PM

maybe disney hired new head writer for pr2009

Harlan Phoenix · 04/21/08, 09:28 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by PrimoPiccolo

Not that I know of. But I'm far from well-informed on the inner workings of PR.

Personally, I think Kalish has had enough time at the reigns. Sloan did the first four and a half seasons, Tzachor the next five and a half, so a PR ingenue like Kalish getting four is plenty.

And while it's been said thousands of times on thousands of boards before, once more won't hurt: Jackie needs to be in charge.

I agree, Jackie's earned it.

Kamen Rider Decade · 04/22/08, 11:48 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Harlan Phoenix

I agree, Jackie's earned it.

How has Jackie earned it?

By turning in an abismal scripts? By sticking with the show so long? Assuming she wrote good scripts and it was ruined by her coworkers she doesn't have the balls nor the integrity to stand up for her work and allows it to be ruined, so she earned the position of taking over Kalish's job by allowing her stuff to be crapped all over?

She hasn't earned it.

The last decent thing she turned out was under Sloan and even then she was still turning out trash.

The only person who has earned anything is the guy in charge of stunts and I still wouldn't want him in the command chair.

Harlan Phoenix · 04/22/08, 03:11 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by The Virginian

How has Jackie earned it?

By turning in an abismal scripts? By sticking with the show so long? Assuming she wrote good scripts and it was ruined by her coworkers she doesn't have the balls nor the integrity to stand up for her work and allows it to be ruined, so she earned the position of taking over Kalish's job by allowing her stuff to be crapped all over?

She hasn't earned it.

The last decent thing she turned out was under Sloan and even then she was still turning out trash.

The only person who has earned anything is the guy in charge of stunts and I still wouldn't want him in the command chair.

Largely, writer's scripts are dictated by the showrunner. Jackie is not the showrunner, therefore her scripts must flow to a certain story dictated to her AND must preform to the content standards of the production company. She's not a terrible writer, she just has to do her job.

Besides, DinoThunder proved that good stuff can be done under Disney's banner. Even if you don't like DinoThunder, it exemplifies the PR mold (craft a new story with Sentai footage) more than any other Disney season. Jackie's been around for a while, she knows the show. I'm confident she'd make a fine showrunner, especially since Disney doesn't necessarily mandate that PR be a mere translation of Sentai, it just seems to be Kalish's philosophy. Otherwise, we wouldn't get something like DinoThunder.

Jackie cares for the show, and we need someone like that.

PrimoPiccolo · 04/22/08, 03:39 PM

Don't mind him. Anyone who doesn't know Jackie Marchand's worth clearly has no idea all the things she was responsible for outside simply 'writing', which includes the whole concept and prop usage of "Fighting Spirit" among many other things.

Sakura3 · 04/22/08, 03:55 PM

I'm still going to watch next year anyways. Besides that I think that we should give whoever this is a chance befoer we make any judgements. I felt that way after I watced Space Patrol Delta and Mystic Force together in 2006. So I'll wait till 2010 before I make any judgemnents.

Harlan Phoenix · 04/22/08, 04:22 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by PrimoPiccolo

Don't mind him. Anyone who doesn't know Jackie Marchand's worth clearly has no idea all the things she was responsible for outside simply 'writing', which includes the whole concept and prop usage of "Fighting Spirit" among many other things.

I like minding him. He's silly.

PrimoPiccolo · 04/22/08, 06:54 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Simango

I think that we should give whoever this is a chance befoer we make any judgements.

We're not even sure there will be a Power Rangers in 2009. :/

04/21/08, 08:21 PM	#33
red timeforce ranger Power Ranger Join Date: 01/14/08 Posts: 122	maybe disney hired new head writer for pr2009 __________________ red timeforce ranger

Similar Threads
Thread	Thread Starter	Forum	Replies	Last Post
Go-Onger in America (2009). What should it be called?	Knightfall	Power Rangers General Discussion	23	09/20/14 11:42 PM
PR News 01/12/08. Animated Power Ranger Series (2009) to be MMPR Reboot	Knightfall	Power Rangers Modern Archives	13	05/19/12 12:16 PM
PR News 31/01/08 Power Rangers 2009 may be live action afterall.	Poweranimals	Power Rangers Modern Archives	30	08/10/08 06:10 PM
PR News 01/02/08. PR to Move Out of New Zealand in 2009? New Filming Location.	Poweranimals	Power Rangers Modern Archives	14	05/28/08 09:35 PM
Working Title for PR 07 revealed	Kamen Rider Decade	Power Rangers Modern Archives	12	03/08/06 08:07 PM

04/21/08, 06:56 PM	#32
PrimoPiccolo *Eternal* Join Date: 04/01/09 Location: 30 minutes from Morphicon Posts: 1,317	Not that I know of. But I'm far from well-informed on the inner workings of PR. Personally, I think Kalish has had enough time at the reigns. Sloan did the first four and a half seasons, Tzachor the next five and a half, so a PR ingenue like Kalish getting four is plenty. And while it's been said thousands of times on thousands of boards before, once more won't hurt: Jackie needs to be in charge.

04/22/08, 03:39 PM	#37
PrimoPiccolo *Eternal* Join Date: 04/01/09 Location: 30 minutes from Morphicon Posts: 1,317	Don't mind him. Anyone who doesn't know Jackie Marchand's worth clearly has no idea all the things she was responsible for outside simply 'writing', which includes the whole concept and prop usage of "Fighting Spirit" among many other things.

04/22/08, 03:55 PM	#38
Sakura3 Power Ranger Join Date: 03/14/08 Posts: 112	I'm still going to watch next year anyways. Besides that I think that we should give whoever this is a chance befoer we make any judgements. I felt that way after I watced Space Patrol Delta and Mystic Force together in 2006. So I'll wait till 2010 before I make any judgemnents.